Showing posts with label patent infringement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label patent infringement. Show all posts
Wednesday, December 21, 2011
ITC SAYS MOTOROLA MOBILITY GUILTY OF MICROSOFT PATENT INFRINGEMENT
The United States International Trade Commission ruled late Tuesday that Motorola Mobility is guilty of infringing on one of Microsoft’s patents. The patent is related to calendar sync and how one might use a device to schedule a meeting, BBC News explained. Microsoft originally filed a suit against Motorola Mobility in August in an attempt to block sales of several Motorola Android smartphones, such as DROID 2, DROID X and several others, and accused Motorola Mobility of infringing on seven total patents. The ITC judge ruled that Motorola Mobility devices do not infringe on six of Microsoft’s patents, however. Microsoft recently filed a similar lawsuit against Barnes & Noble, and the company has already reached licensing agreements with HTC, Samsung, ViewSonic and several other firms.
Labels:
itc,
Microsoft,
Motorola mobility,
patent infringement
Tuesday, October 18, 2011
ITC JUDGE SAYS APPLE DOES NOT INFRINGE ON HTC PATENTS
An ITC judge has ruled on HTC's first complaint against Apple from back in May of 2010, finding no violation of the patents in question on the part of Apple. As FOSS Patents notes, however, the ruling hardly puts an end to the dispute between the two companies, and HTC certainly seems to be in it for the long haul. Its general counsel told CNET that "this is only one step of many in these legal proceedings," and that, "we are confident we have a strong case for the ITC appeals process and are fully prepared to protect our intellectual property."
Thursday, September 8, 2011
HTC COUNTER SUES APPLE WITH FORMER GOOGLE PATENTS
There's a fresh new twist in the never ending Apple / HTC patent battle. The Taiwanese handset manufacturer is hitting back against Apple using newly obtained firepower: nine patents picked up from Google last week. The patents, which began life under Palm, Motorola and Openwave Systems, were transferred to HTC on September 1st.
Apple has sued HTC for patent infringement as well over HTC's use of Android.
Tuesday, July 26, 2011
MICROSOFT SUED FOR PATENT INFRINGEMENT IN KINECT CONTROLLER
Microsoft is being sued for patent infringement over motion-sensing technology used in its blockbuster gaming accessory, the Microsoft Kinect. Ohio-based Impulse Technology has filed a complaint alleging that Microsoft’s Kinect controller infringes on seven of its technology patents. One patent referenced in the lawsuit covers “wide variety of games where the movement of a player is tracked in three dimensions…and certain exercise games where the motion of the player is tracked to effect movement of a virtual avatar, and the exertion of the user is monitored, including where the tracking of the player is done by the use of a camera.” A separate patent describes an “education system challenging a subject’s physiologic and kinesthetic systems to synergistically enhance cognitive function.”
Impulse Technology is seeking a permanent injunction to block the import and sale of Microsoft’s Kinect, and it is also suing Electronic Arts, Konami and Sega for developing Xbox 360 games that utilize Kinect and infringe on its patents. Impulse is seeking damages, treble damages, interest, and attorney fees from Microsoft as well. The Kinect motion-based video game controller has been a smash hit for Microsoft, having set numerous sales records since its launch. This past March, Microsoft announced that it had sold 10 million Kinect controllers since the device’s launch just before the holidays last year.
Labels:
controller,
kinect,
lawsuit,
legal,
Microsoft,
patent infringement,
technology
Monday, July 25, 2011
ORACLE MUST RE-SUBMIT DAMAGES COST FOR GOOGLE; JUDGE TELLS THEM TO BE REALISTIC
The war between Google and Oracle is far from over, but the big G keeps racking up tiny victories in what are admittedly modest battles. Now Oracle has been told to go back to the drawing board with its damages report. Originally Oracle sought $2.6 billion, but its theories were largely dismissed and Judge William Alsup suggested an alternative starting point of roughly $100 million. The company still has an opportunity to present a new report, one that will likely seek much more than the proposed $100 million, but things are looking increasingly tough for the claimant.
It wasn't all good news for Google, though. While the judge told Oracle to narrow its focus from Android as a whole to just specific infringing features, he did agree that related advertising revenue should be included in the theoretical royalty base. He also offered harsh criticism for what he viewed as its "brazen" disregard for intellectual property rights.
The trial is still scheduled for October, so we should have a better idea of how this whole thing will play out by Halloween.
Labels:
damages,
Google,
lawsuit,
legal,
oracle,
patent infringement,
William Alsup
Friday, June 24, 2011
USPTO REJECTS SEVERAL OF ORACLE'S PATENT CLAIMS AGAINST GOOGLE
Much ink has been spilled about Oracle's lawsuit against Google for Android's allegedly unlawful use of Java, and rightfully so, considering Team Ellison's seeking to take more than a billion dollar chunk out of Google's bottom line. Just because Oracle's damage calculations add up to ten figures doesn't mean that the court will agree with them, however. And, there's a long legal road to be tread before the court can assign a dollar value to the case -- namely it must determine if the patent claims and copyrights are valid and whether Android actually infringes them.
That's why Google requested the USPTO re-examine the patents asserted by Oracle, as the process gives Google a shot at invalidating them outside the courtroom. It looks like the strategy is paying off, as one of those re-exams recently resulted in a rejection of 17 of the patent's 21 claims -- which reduces the number of claims Oracle can assert in court accordingly. Of course, those four remaining claims plus the 118 contained in the other six asserted patents (should they survive the re-examination process) could still spell doom for the little green bots, but it is a victory, albeit a modest one, for the team in Mountain View. So, Oracle may have a few less IP bullets to fire Google's way, but it's still got plenty of other legal ammo left.
Labels:
Google,
lawsuit,
legal,
oracle,
patent infringement,
US Patent Trade office,
uspto
Saturday, June 11, 2011
APPLE FILES MOTION TO INTERVENE IN LODSYS CASE AGAINST DEVELOPERS
Apple's already made its position on the whole Lodsys situation pretty clear, and it's now taken things one step further after the patent holder hit iOS developers with a lawsuit at the end of last month. As noted by Florian Mueller of FOSS Patents, Apple has filed a motion to intervene in the case, and he says Apple is "fairly likely" to be admitted as an intervener based on precedent. In the case that happens, Apple has also concurrently filed its answer to the complaint and its counterclaim, which unsurprisingly line up with its earlier position on the matter: that Apple has already licensed the patents in question on the developers' behalf, and that they are "entitled to use this technology free from any infringement claims by Lodsys."
Labels:
Apple,
developers,
lawsuit,
lodsys,
patent infringement
Friday, June 10, 2011
MICROSOFT LOSES PATENT INFRINGEMENT CASE, MUST PAY $290 MILLION
We've diligently followed the Microsoft v. i4i Limited Partnership patent dispute as it wound its way through the courts, and now comes the day of reckoning: by a unanimous decision, the US Supreme Court has upheld the patent-infringement finding against Redmond. For those of you just catching up, MS had been taken to court by Toronto-based i4i over a portfolio of XML-related patents, patents it had already offered to license to the software behemoth.
In court, Microsoft claimed it had not infringed and that the patents were invalid; a 2009 Texas court disagreed and awarded $200 million in damages. A subsequent appeal failed. Oh, and the government sided with i4i. Today's Supreme Court verdict upholds the lower courts' decisions: Microsoft Word is an infringing product, and the company now owes $290 million. The finding likely won't affect consumers, as the offending versions of Word are now obsolete. Still, $290 million isn't chump change, even for the world's largest software company.
Saturday, May 14, 2011
LODSYS SUING iOS DEVS FOR IN-APP PURCHASING
A handful of iOS developers received letters this week from a patent holding firm claiming that their applications that offer in-app purchases infringe on the firm's intellectual property (IP).
The letter threatens legal action if developers don't license the patent within 21 days. Lodsys, the firm in question, has apparently patented a system that collects usage data and facilitates feedback between a customer and vendor, though it doesn't address financial transactions specifically. The allegedly infringing applications use Apple's in-app purchase tool to encourage users to upgrade to a paid version after downloading a free app.
Though it's possible that Lodsys has sent a similar warning to Apple, only individual developers confirmed receiving the document.
The developers are understandably unwilling to share too many details at this point -- even though Apple developed the framework, developers could still be liable. Lodsys appears to be in the business of launching suits referencing U.S. patent 7,222,078, having gone after Canon, HP, Samsung, and other giants earlier this year. As the developers that have come to light so far are independent, with limited budgets, some have reached out to Apple legal for assistance, and are awaiting response.
Labels:
Apple,
developers,
in-app purchasing,
ios,
lawsuit,
legal,
lodsys,
patent,
patent infringement,
suit
KODAK WINS IN APPLE'S PATENT INFRINGEMENT CASE
An International Trade Commission (ITC) judge has ruled that Kodak did not infringe upon camera patents held by Apple. Reuters is reporting that an administrative law judge rejected the Cupertino-company’s claims, with a final decision by the ITC due on September 19th.
Kodak, although not as prominent as it once was when film reigned supreme, still holds a treasure-trove of patents. “Many investors see Kodak’s value in its lucrative portfolio of intellectual property,” reads the report. “It has more than 1,000 patents and it made an estimated $630 million in 2010 from its licenses. But analysts have said this revenue from licenses is unpredictable and the portfolio might eventually dwindle.”
Kodak has a pending suit filed against both Apple and Research In Motion, again surrounding smartphone camera technology, that is set to be decided upon on May 23rd.
Labels:
Apple,
international trade commission,
itc,
Kodak,
patent infringement
Monday, May 2, 2011
DISH NETWORK AND ECHOSTAR TO PAY TIVO $500 MILLION TO SETTLE LAWSUIT
Dish Network, EchoStar and TiVo have come to a settlement on their long running patent dispute (since 2006) that will see the satellite company pay $500 million to settle all ongoing litigation. We stopped covering the various court judgements in this case last year as each side continued to file one stay and injunction after another, but this time it's finally over. The most recent court judgement came April 20th in the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit and found EchoStar in contempt of an earlier injunction despite modifications to its DVR software.
The companies have licensed certain patents to each other, including the infamous Time Warp patent that was at the heart of the dispute. Details are in the press release after the break, but TiVo's scored an upfront $300 million cash payment (Dish Network is also reporting today it added 58,000 subscribers and had a net income of $549 million last quarter, we guess there was some loose change rolling around after its Blockbuster and DBSD purchases), with the remaining $200 million to be paid out between 2012 and 2017.
Labels:
dish network,
echostar,
injunction,
lawsuit,
patent infringement,
settlement,
time warp,
tivo
Friday, April 22, 2011
SAMSUNG SLAMS APPLE WITH PATENT INFRINGEMENT SUIT IN EXCHANGE FOR APPLE SUING THEM
Samsung on Friday filed multiple patent infringement suits against Apple. Just four days following Apple’s filing of a lawsuit alleging Samsung smartphones like the Galaxy S “copy Apple’s technology, user interface and innovative style,” Samsung has filed three separate suits alleging infringement of a total of ten patents. The suits were filed in Seoul Central District Court, Korea; Tokyo, Japan; and in Manheim, Germany. In a statement, Samsung said it is “responding actively to the legal action taken against us in order to protect our intellectual property and to ensure our continued innovation and growth in the mobile communications business.” Ebb and flow… yin and yang… suits and countersuits.
Labels:
Apple,
lawsuit,
patent infringement,
samsung
Tuesday, April 19, 2011
MICROSOFT, i4i SPAT HEADS TO US SUPREME COURT
A four-year old patent dispute is about to be put to rest. In a complaint originally filed in 2007, Toronto-based firm i4i alleged that Microsoft used proprietary code to display XML files in its Microsoft Word 2003 product. A Texas jury ruled in favor of i4i in August of 2009, and awarded the company a $290 million settlement — Microsoft was also barred from selling Word 2003 until i4i’s code was removed.
The U.S. software giant has excavated the bits in question, but Microsoft is looking to the country’s highest court for a more preferable decision. After several failed attempts to have i4i’s patents reviewed and invalidated by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, the Supreme Court has agreed to hear the case. Both Microsoft and i4i will be given 30 minutes to explain to the eight Justices — Chief Justice John Roberts has recused himself — why the patent is valid. But the case will take on a greater meaning, going well beyond this one piece of intellectual property. Microsoft will argue that patent law, as it currently stands, is stifling innovation, whilst i4i will argue the contrary.
The court began hearing arguments this Monday, and its decision is expected to have a significant, and potentially far reaching, impact on patent cases currently in waiting.
Labels:
code,
i4i,
lawsuit,
Microsoft,
patent infringement,
supreme court,
xml
Saturday, March 26, 2011
ITC RULES APPLE DID NOT INFRINGE ON NOKIA PATENTS
An International Trade Commission panel on Friday ruled on a patent infringement suit filed by Nokia against Apple in May 2010. In the suit, Nokia alleged that Apple’s iPhone infringed on multiple Nokia patents covering wireless data transmission, data encryption and other related technologies. The ITC found that Apple did not infringe on any of the five patents named by Nokia in its complaint. The suit was one several patent-related suits exchanged by Nokia and Apple in recent years in the United States and in Europe.
Labels:
Apple,
itc,
Nokia,
patent infringement,
trade commision
Monday, March 21, 2011
MICROSOFT SUES BARNES & NOBLE, FOXCONN AND INVENTEC FOR PATENT INFRINGEMENT
Microsoft has announced it will file suit against Barnes & Noble, Foxconn, and Inventec for patent infringement. The three, seemingly unrelated companies collaborate to manufacture the Barns & Noble branded, Android-based eReader. “The Android platform infringes a number of Microsoft’s patents, and companies manufacturing and shipping Android devices must respect our intellectual property rights,” said Horacio Gutierrez, Microsoft’s Deputy General Counsel.
Microsoft has setup a patent licensing program for Android vendors to mitigate instances of infringement upon the patents in question — Taiwanese company HTC subscribes to said program. “We have tried for over a year to reach licensing agreements with Barnes & Noble, Foxconn and Inventec” Gutierrez added. “Their refusals to take licenses leave us no choice but to bring legal action to defend our innovations.”
Thursday, March 10, 2011
COURT RULES AGAINST LG, SONY CAN CONTINUE TO SHIP PLAYSTATION 3 IN EUROPE
The Hague's civil court of justice has just ruled in Sony's favor in its dispute with LG, and ordered that the 300,000 PS3s currently seized by customs be released to Sony for distribution across the continent. LG has also reportedly been ordered to pay €130,000 in legal fees -- and if it doesn't comply, it will face a fine of €200,000 per day until it does. That doesn't mean that the tussle between the two companies is over, however, as this ruling doesn't have anything to do with the patents at the heart of the dispute.
Labels:
hague,
lawsuit,
lg,
patent,
patent infringement,
playstation 3,
Sony
Monday, October 18, 2010
HYPERMAC TO STOP SELLING CHARGING CABLES
HyperMac will stop selling MacBook charging cables and car chargers on November 2nd, under potential legal threat from Apple. Apple sued Sanho for patent infringement of their MagSafe cables, similar to MacHype's cables. HyperMac sent the following email to its customers:
Dear Valued Customers,
As part of our ongoing comprehensive licensing negotiations with Apple regarding a wide array of technologies and issues, we have decided to cease the sale of the MacBook charging cables and car charger on November 2, 2010.
While we will continue to sell the same batteries together with the rest of our product line after November 2nd, they will not be able to charge MacBooks without the cables.
If you wish to get the world's ONLY external battery and car charger solution that works with ALL MacBook, MacBook Air and MacBook Pro (supports dual voltage) as well as the iPad, iPhone 3/3GS/4, iPod and all other USB devices, NOW is the time.
On November 2, 2010 00:00 U.S. Pacific Time, they will gone for good.
As we have very limited stocks, do order early to avoid disappointment. We will continue to sell until November 2nd and while stocks last.
We wish thank the many customers who have already gotten the HyperMac External MacBook Battery and those of you that gave us wonderful reviews.
HyperMac will continue to sell the charging batteries, but without the necessary cables this is a bit pointless. [Engadget]
Dear Valued Customers,
As part of our ongoing comprehensive licensing negotiations with Apple regarding a wide array of technologies and issues, we have decided to cease the sale of the MacBook charging cables and car charger on November 2, 2010.
While we will continue to sell the same batteries together with the rest of our product line after November 2nd, they will not be able to charge MacBooks without the cables.
If you wish to get the world's ONLY external battery and car charger solution that works with ALL MacBook, MacBook Air and MacBook Pro (supports dual voltage) as well as the iPad, iPhone 3/3GS/4, iPod and all other USB devices, NOW is the time.
On November 2, 2010 00:00 U.S. Pacific Time, they will gone for good.
As we have very limited stocks, do order early to avoid disappointment. We will continue to sell until November 2nd and while stocks last.
We wish thank the many customers who have already gotten the HyperMac External MacBook Battery and those of you that gave us wonderful reviews.
HyperMac will continue to sell the charging batteries, but without the necessary cables this is a bit pointless. [Engadget]
Saturday, October 16, 2010
MOTOROLA TAKES OFFENSIVE AGAINST APPLE
Motorola has asked a judge in Delaware to invalidate 24 patents Apple is using to sue HTC. According to the lawsuit, Motorola and Apple have been in negotiations to license each others patents and avoid legal actions. Motorola is new suing Apple with three lawsuits and an International Trade Commission complaint over what it claims are 18 violations of their patents.
Apple sued HTC earlier this year claiming infringment on 24 of its patents related to graphical user interfaces and other technologies. The lawsuit is aimed squarely at Google's Android operating system. Motorola is trying to have the patents declared invalid in a preemptive move before Apple comes after them. f
Motorola is also facing a set of lawsuits by Microsoft for nine counts of patent infringement, also related to Motorola's use of Android.
Should software patents be valid, especially if they are obvious and common? Tell us your thoughts in the comments section. [Ars Technica]
Apple sued HTC earlier this year claiming infringment on 24 of its patents related to graphical user interfaces and other technologies. The lawsuit is aimed squarely at Google's Android operating system. Motorola is trying to have the patents declared invalid in a preemptive move before Apple comes after them. f
Motorola is also facing a set of lawsuits by Microsoft for nine counts of patent infringement, also related to Motorola's use of Android.
Should software patents be valid, especially if they are obvious and common? Tell us your thoughts in the comments section. [Ars Technica]
Labels:
Apple,
lawsuit,
Microsoft,
Motorola,
patent infringement
Saturday, October 2, 2010
MICROSOFT SUES MOTOROLA FOR PATENT INFRINGEMENT
It was only a matter of time before this happened. A few weeks ago Microsoft released a statement saying due to lawsuits for patent infringement Android was more expensive than Windows Phone 7 (WP7). Now, Microsoft is suing one of the largest Android manufacturers for patent infringement.....surprise!
Microsoft is claiming infringement on nine software patents. These are:
Microsoft is claiming infringement on nine software patents. These are:
- 5,579,517: Common name space for long and short filenames
- 5,758,352: Common name space for long and short filenames
- 6,621,746: Monitoring entropic conditions of a flash memory device as an indicator for invoking erasure operations
- 6,826,762: Radio interface layer in a cell phone with a set of APIs having a hardware-independent proxy layer and a hardware-specific driver layer
- 6,909,910: Method and system for managing changes to a contact database
- 7,644,376: Flexible architecture for notifying applications of state changes
- 5,664,133: Context sensitive menu system/menu behavior
- 6,578,054: Method and system for supporting off-line mode of operation and synchronization using resource state information
- 6,370,566: Generating meeting requests and group scheduling from a mobile device
In a nutshell the patents all cover basic smartphone experiences related to email, calendar and contact syncing; scheduling meetings; notifying applications of changes in signal strength and battery power.
Microsoft released a statement saying "We have a responsibility to our customers, partners, and shareholders to safeguard the billions of dollars we invest each year in bringing innovative software products and services to market. Our action today merely seeks to ensure respect for our intellectual property rights infringed by Android devices; and judging by the recent actions by Apple and Oracle, we are not alone in this respect" [Ars Technica]
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

















